Kari de Pryck & Océane Garandel

Student role-play

Kari de Pryck & Océane Garandel

Gaélane Wolff

Engage
All projects
Rendre actifs
Project

This activity encourages students to analyze environmental controversy by identifying its key players and issues, and then to convey its complexity through a structured oral presentation.

Back to the catalogue

Initial situation

The program is integrated into a 24-hour lecture course on international environmental policy. While this format allows for the exploration of concepts and theoretical frameworks, it remains difficult for students to fully grasp the complexity of the debates. The tutoring format has therefore evolved over time. Previous formats based on a WordPress site or a written report have been replaced by an oral presentation, which is more engaging and better suited to the targeted skills.

Project implementation

Environmental issues lie at the heart of controversies involving numerous stakeholders (scientists, government agencies, businesses, NGOs, and citizen groups) and where scientific, political, and economic concerns intersect. The goal is to supplement the course with an activity that allows students to analyze a real-world controversy and understand its dynamics.

The tutorial complements the lecture course with 8 hours spread over two months. At the beginning of the semester, instructors propose about fifteen controversies. Students select the controversies that interest them most via Moodle and are then divided into groups of four or five.

Each group investigates a controversy. Students must identify the stakeholders involved, their positions, their arguments, and their methods of action. They also analyze the alliances, oppositions, and issues at stake. A timeline of the debate is constructed to identify key moments and periods of intensity. The course places central importance on visualizing the controversy, inviting students to create networks of actors and to represent their positions on various issues.

The tutorials are organized into four sessions. The first session is devoted to introducing the groups, explaining the methodology, and setting the framework for the work. The second session begins the research process by creating a timeline of the controversies assigned to the students and mapping out their key actors. The third session allows for a deeper analysis and discussion of the actors’ positions on the various issues at stake in the controversies. During this session, the groups present the progress of their work and begin preparing their final presentation. The teaching team participates in the development of staging ideas, guiding the students but allowing them creative freedom between the third and fourth sessions. The fourth session is dedicated to the final presentation. Students must present their controversy in a 10-minute staged performance.

Students must present their controversy in 10 minutes in the form of a staged performance. The format is open (roundtable, newscast, courtroom, street interviews, etc.) but must clearly convey the complexity of the debate. A discussion with questions follows each presentation.

The grade is split equally between the written course exam and the presentation. An evaluation rubric specifies the expectations (analysis of the actors, understanding of the issues, quality of the presentation).

Thoughts and advice

This approach fosters student engagement. By taking on the roles of the key players, students come to understand their perspectives and move beyond a simplistic view of the controversies. The exercise develops the ability to synthesize a complex situation and present it in a structured manner within a limited time frame. It also helps students develop oral communication skills and teamwork.

Implementation is relatively simple, but regular follow-up is necessary. It is important to set aside time for discussions with the groups between sessions to ensure progress and the quality of the analysis. Particular attention should be paid to group dynamics and the division of labor.

Finally, the oral presentation and Q&A allow for verification of content mastery, even in a context where students may use AI tools.