This project is archived. This course has changed since its publication and the teaching team can no longer be reached.
Junod Perron Noëlle

Formative Stations and board game

Junod Perron Noëlle

Engage Archived
All projects
Formative Stations and board game
Project

Senior students mentor junior students to develop their clinical skills through role-playing and a collaborative board game.

Course: Compétences cliniques / Bachelor
Since:2022
Back to the catalogue

Initial situation

During medical school, clinical skills (information gathering, physical examination and communication with the patient) are learned and taught during the bachelor’s 2 and 3 years, as well as at the start of Master 1. This teaching consists of 80 seminars over two years and 4 18-minute training stations during which students interact with a standardized patient presenting a complaint. These stations are supervised by teaching physicians. However, despite the breadth of this program, medical students often feel inadequately prepared and ask for more clinical skills practice in preparation for the end-of-3rd-year summative exam and subsequent clinical placements. They also report a lack of practice in acquiring clinical skills in certain systems deemed difficult. They also admit to learning by rote the questions to ask and the elements to look for in the clinical examination, with little or no practice in clinical reasoning, a key skill for practising as doctors.

Experience during the COVID period has shown that master’s students involved as tutors (in place of experienced clinicians who have become unavailable) in clinical skills teaching activities have teaching skills (quality of feedback and teaching of skills) equivalent or even better than experienced clinicians after a short training period. Following on from this experience, two learning and teaching activities conducted “for and by peers” among students at the Faculty of Medicine were developed in response to needs expressed by the latter.

Project implementation

A group of around ten medical students in the Masters years has developed two optional “for and by peers” activities aimed at filling identified gaps. The activities, attended by junior bachelor students, are facilitated by senior master students, trained in the pedagogical techniques of small-group facilitation and feedback during a 2-hour seminar.

The first activity focuses on learning clinical skills in anatomical systems considered to be complex. It takes the form of a seminar during which junior students have the opportunity to practice these clinical skills (information gathering, clinical examination and communication) by taking turns playing the clinician, patient or observer. Nine clinical situations have been developed with the help of experienced clinicians, three of which are practiced during each seminar. The three clinical situations deal with systems that are insufficiently mastered, such as osteoarticular, neurological, gynecological, lymphatic or life-threatening emergency systems. At the end of each situation, the clinician performs a self-assessment of the skills used (what worked well and what was more difficult), followed by feedback from the observer. All observations and perceptions, including those of the patient, are pooled and discussed with the senior student.

The second activity involves learning clinical reasoning in the form of a collaborative board game. Learning is interactive, concrete and based on common clinical situations. Based on a complaint recorded on a card, junior students must generate diagnostic hypotheses by naming the anatomical systems (cardiac, respiratory, etc.) or processes (infectious, inflammatory, traumatic, etc.) possibly involved. Then, on the basis of additional data revealed to them in the course of an anamnesis, they are asked to generate diagnostic hypotheses for each of the systems/processes. Cards relating to these systems/processes and possible diagnoses are gradually laid out on a game board, and penalty tokens assigned if any data is missing or wrong. The second activity involves learning clinical reasoning in the form of a collaborative board game. Learning is interactive, concrete and based on common clinical situations. Based on a complaint recorded on a card, junior students must generate diagnostic hypotheses by naming the anatomical systems (cardiac, respiratory, etc.) or processes (infectious, inflammatory, traumatic, etc.) possibly involved. Then, on the basis of additional data revealed to them in the course of an anamnesis, they are asked to generate diagnostic hypotheses for each of the systems/processes. Cards relating to these systems/processes and possible diagnoses are gradually laid out on a game board, and penalty tokens assigned if any data is missing or wrong.

Thoughts and advice

One of the strengths of this project lies in the fact that it is student-driven, thus facilitating good cognitive congruence - the fact that students are clearer about what their peers have to learn. In this way, it has been developed in response to an existing need.

These activities are optional and facilitated by students, without requiring additional resources from the Faculty. The fact that a significant number of students take part in these activities as seniors, without financial compensation, indicates that there is a clear interest on their part in getting involved in the training of younger students, and that they benefit from it. Even if the senior students train each other year after year, the teacher points out that it is still necessary to provide a framework to enable the project to evolve and endure over the years.

By increasing junior students’ exposure to the clinic in the form of different simulation activities, these activities help them prepare for exams and better articulate anamnesis and examination skills with clinical reasoning. In fact, the teacher notes a higher success rate in exams with simulated patients at the end of the bachelor’s years for those who took part in the first activity.

Peer learning creates a safe, caring learning environment. Senior students also have the opportunity to review their skills and master them better so that they can teach others. Above all, they acquire facilitation and feedback techniques that will be useful for their future professional careers. Indeed, supervision of clinical reasoning and feedback are key elements in stimulating the training of aspiring doctors or those in clinical training, and taking part in these activities helps them to develop their professional identity.

The teacher points out that these activities should not be seen as a substitute for teaching by experienced doctors, especially for complex, specialized subjects requiring specific expertise. On the other hand, for the acquisition of basic skills, these learning and teaching modalities are very effective and stimulating.

Student feedback

Activity 1

Junior students

“Very rewarding, especially thanks to the point of view of the students who themselves have been in our shoes and passed.” “[Strengths:] Practicing for the clinical exam, which we don’t practice much in the courses.”

“[Strengths:] Valuable tips and advice from upperclassmen The ease and comfort of working with other students.” “[Strong points:] The fact that it’s training and that we give each other advice.”

Senior students

“I learned a lot as an instructor about how to give constructive and useful feedback. Also on how to manage and facilitate a group.” “Re-learning things in a precise way to be able to answer students in their questions.” “The students who signed up were very motivated and involved in the exercise I don’t know if everyone would necessarily be if it was compulsory.” “Interaction with other students from years down the line we project ourselves into the past and put ourselves in their shoes. We try to create the best possible learning environment and avoid the awkwardness is often present at stations of this type but with a supervising doctor.”

Activity 2

Junior students

“I’ve learned not to focus a complaint on one or two systems, but to broaden my reasoning.”

“This allows us to see a complaint in its entirety and not just in relation to one system. It also helps us remember illnesses and how they relate to the patient’s complaint.”

“This game has enabled me to improve my clinical reasoning by thinking about all systems, as opposed to conventional CC/SF, in which the focus is on a single system.”

Senior students

“I learned how to lead/stimulate the search for diagnostic hypotheses.

“I was able to review clinical aspects of anamnesis and clinical examination for each pathology, I was asked uninteresting questions that I hadn’t always thought of.” “A little more time should be allowed or simpler vignettes made to avoid being rushed. Students ask a lot of interesting questions related to the vignettes and it would be nice to have more time to be able to answer them.”