Marlyne Sahakian

Theoretical Theatre & Posters

Marlyne Sahakian

Engage
All projects
Theoretical Theatre & Posters
Project

The pedagogical approach of the teacher consists in personifying the theories by presenting to the students characters embodying different perspectives of the sociology of consumption. These characters debate and take positions on objects in the course, thus offering a vivid and contrasting understanding of the theories discussed.

Course: Sociologie de la consommation / Bachelor
Since:2018
Back to the catalogue

Initial situation

The objective of this sociology of consumption course is to share with students the different ways of understanding consumption. To do this, the teacher presents the content of several theoretical articles. However, since the acquisition of theoretical content is not always easy, she wanted to make it easier by making it more playful by drawing inspiration from theoretical theater.

Project implementation

The pedagogical approach proposed by the teacher is to personify the theories. She is inspired by theoretical theater: without embodying the characters, the teacher presents the students with characters embodying each of the theories discussed and defending them. The students are introduced to five main characters who represent different ways of understanding consumption in sociology: Dorothée Distinction, Carla Critique, Sylvie Signes, Pénélope Pratiques Sociales and Sissi Sociotechnique. Each one presents herself by reflecting the theory she embodies. For example, Dorothée Distinction explains that for her: “consumption serves to distinguish oneself by social class and to distinguish oneself in power relationships with others” or Sylvie Signes explains: “Everything I do is endowed with meaning, I see in goods and services signs that help me communicate with others”. These characters are opposed to other characters who do not come from sociology, such as Hortense Homo-economicus.

During each class, the teacher introduces the historical and theoretical context through these characters and then has them debate among themselves about the consumer object chosen for the class. For example, the teacher may address the subject of jeans and the ethical or ecological issues they raise. The characters take a position on this object in accordance with the theories they represent. Consonance, tensions or an epistemological rupture may appear between them.

The course is evaluated on a continuous basis. Students will submit an individual assignment worth 60% and a group assignment worth 40%. A bonus is given for attendance and active participation in the course. In the individual work, students must demonstrate their understanding of the conceptual frameworks and relate them to each other, often by putting into dialogue the different conceptual characters encountered during the course. During group work, students in groups of 3 to 4 (formed by affinity or through Moodle) must orally present a poster (from a template) on an object of consumer sociology related to social practice theory. The evaluation is based on the content of the poster in question and answer format and the oral presentation (20%) and an explanatory sheet to be handed in beforehand (20%). The presentations take place over several days at the end of the semester, in conference mode in the university’s corridors. A prize is awarded to the best poster, evaluated by the other students.

Thoughts and advice

The teacher reports that in her experience it is necessary to pay attention to the gender of the characters even if it seems trivial. While initially both male and female characters were used, debates between these characters tended to make the female character too superficial (e.g., Carl Critique castigated Penelope Pratiques); therefore, all characters became female in 2020. In addition, care must be taken to ensure that the characters are grounded in the content of the articles proposed in the bibliography.

There will always be students who find the characters unnecessary. However, the teacher notes that most students appreciate the playfulness of the characters, which makes it easier for them to grasp conceptual frameworks that are usually difficult for some to access.

Student feedback

“The approach to conceptual frameworks is fun and facilitates learning compared to a typical lecture.” “The teaching method is interesting especially in a Bachelor’s degree where all the courses require us to do the same type of work.” “Creating characters that each represent a different aspect of consumption and are associated with different authors gives us a better understanding of the issues in the sociology of consumption. Plus, it’s more fun and keeps our attention on the course. The themes of the courses are on very current issues in consumption and which we often hear about in everyday life, and I therefore find it interesting to be able to deepen them in class with scientific literature. The assignments, in which we have to be creative, are different from the other assignments we have to do in the other courses. I really enjoyed doing the first assignment by putting the different characters in dialogue with a more creative form.” “Strengths of the course are: personification of concepts; connection to contemporary consumerism; individual work (+ encouraged to do it in original ways); poster, different teaching method.” “The course is an introduction to the different theoretical currents in the sociology of consumption: it gives an overview and allows us to confront, compare and challenge the different frameworks. The evaluation methods and in particular the conversation between the different theoretical frameworks on an object are interesting. The possibility of evaluating the working group to post it if necessary is also appreciated.”